Retracted: Molecular characterization of excipients' preferential interactions with therapeutic monoclonal antibodies.

Retraction: Molecular characterization of excipients' preferential interactions with therapeutic monoclonal antibodies by Jehoon Kim, Mark R. H. Krebs and Bernhardt L. Trout The above article from the Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmacology, first published online on 4 August 2017 in Wiley Online Library (wileyonlinelibrary.com), has been retracted by agreement between the authors, the journal Editor-in-Chief, Professor David Jones, and John Wiley & Sons Ltd. The authors discovered that the analysis of simulations was faulty making the data incorrect. Reference Kim J et al. Molecular characterization of excipients' preferential interactions with therapeutic monoclonal antibodies. J Pharm Pharmacol 2017. https://doi.org/10.1111/jphp.12787.

CDR-restricted engineering of native human scFvs creates highly stable and soluble bifunctional antibodies for subcutaneous delivery.

While myriad molecular formats for bispecific antibodies have been examined to date, the simplest structures are often based on the scFv. Issues with stability and manufacturability in scFv-based bispecific molecules, however, have been a significant hindrance to their development, particularly for high-concentration, stable formulations that allow subcutaneous delivery. Our aim was to generate a tetravalent bispecific molecule targeting two inflammatory mediators for synergistic immune modulation. We focused on an scFv-Fc-scFv format, with a flexible (A4T)3 linker coupling an additional scFv to the C-terminus of an scFv-Fc. While one of the lead scFvs isolated directly from a naïve library was well-behaved and sufficiently potent, the parental anti-CXCL13 scFv 3B4 required optimization for affinity, stability, and cynomolgus ortholog cross-reactivity. To achieve this, we eschewed framework-based stabilizing mutations in favor of complementarity-determining region (CDR) mutagenesis and re-selection for simultaneous improvements in both affinity and thermal stability. Phage-displayed 3B4 CDR-mutant libraries were used in an aggressive "hammer-hug" selection strategy that incorporated thermal challenge, functional, and biophysical screening. This approach identified leads with improved stability and>18-fold, and 4,100-fold higher affinity for both human and cynomolgus CXCL13, respectively. Improvements were exclusively mediated through only 4 mutations in VL-CDR3. Lead scFvs were reformatted into scFv-Fc-scFvs and their biophysical properties ranked. Our final candidate could be formulated in a standard biopharmaceutical platform buffer at 100 mg/ml with<2% high molecular weight species present after 7 weeks at 4 °C and viscosity<15 cP. This workflow has facilitated the identification of a truly manufacturable scFv-based bispecific therapeutic suitable for subcutaneous administration.

High-throughput measurement, correlation analysis, and machine-learning predictions for pH and thermal stabilities of Pfizer-generated antibodies.

Generating stable antibodies is an important goal in the development of antibody-based drugs. Often, thermal stability is assumed predictive of overall stability. To test this, we used different internally created antibodies and first studied changes in antibody structure as a function of pH, using the dye ANS. Comparison of the pH(50) values, the midpoint of the transition from the high-pH to the low-pH conformation, allowed us for the first time to rank antibodies based on their pH stability. Next, thermal stability was probed by heating the protein in the presence of the dye Sypro Orange. A new data analysis method allowed extraction of all three antibody unfolding transitions and showed close correspondence to values obtained by differential scanning calorimetry. T(1%) , the temperature at which 1% of the protein is unfolded, was also determined. Importantly, no correlations could be found between thermal stability and pH(50) , suggesting that to accurately quantify antibody stability, different measures of protein stability are necessary. The experimental data were further analyzed using a machine-learning approach with a trained model that allowed the prediction of biophysical stability using primary sequence alone. The pH stability predictions proved most successful and were accurate to within pH ±0.2.

Protein aggregation: more than just fibrils.

The aggregation of misfolded proteins into amyloid fibrils, and the importance of this step for various diseases, is well known. However, it is becoming apparent that the fibril is not the only structure that aggregating proteins of widely different types may adopt. Around the isoelectric point, when the net charge is essentially zero, rather monodisperse and quasi-amorphous nanoscale particles form. These particles are found to contain limited runs of beta-sheet structure, but their overall organization is random. These nanoparticles have the potential to be useful for such applications as the slow release of drugs. The amyloid fibrils form away from the isoelectric point, but over certain ranges of, e.g., pH, the fibrils themselves do not exist freely, but form suprafibrillar aggregates termed spherulites. These consist of fibrils radiating from a central nucleus, and form by new species attaching to the ends of growing fibrils, rather than by the aggregation of pre-existing fibrils. Under the polarizing light microscope, they exhibit a Maltese cross shape due to their symmetry. The rate of aggregation is determined by factors involving (at least) protein size, concentration, presence of salt and charge. The occurrence of spherulites, which have been found in vivo as well as in vitro, appears to be generic, although the factors which determine the equilibrium between free fibril and spherulite are not as yet clear.

Amyloid fibril-like structure underlies the aggregate structure across the pH range for beta-lactoglobulin.

The protein beta-lactoglobulin aggregates into two apparently distinct forms under different conditions: amyloid fibrils at pH values away from the isoelectric point, and spherical aggregates near it. To understand this apparent dichotomy in behavior, we studied the internal structure of the spherical aggregates by employing a range of biophysical approaches. Fourier transform infrared studies show the aggregates have a high beta-sheet content that is distinct from the native beta-lactoglobulin structure. The structures also bind the amyloidophilic dye thioflavin-T, and wide-angle x-ray diffraction showed reflections corresponding to spacings typically observed for amyloid fibrils composed of beta-lactoglobulin. Combined with small-angle x-ray scattering data indicating the presence of one-dimensional linear aggregates at the molecular level, these findings indicate strongly that the aggregates contain amyloid-like substructure. Incubation of beta-lactoglobulin at pH values increasingly removed from the isoelectric point resulted in the increasing appearance of fibrillar species, rather than spherical species shown by electron microscopy. Taken together, these results suggest that amyloid-like beta-sheet structures underlie protein aggregation over a much broader range of conditions than previously believed. Furthermore, the results suggest that there is a continuum of beta-sheet structure of varying regularity underlying the aggregate morphology, from very regular amyloid fibrils at high charge to short stretches of amyloid-like fibrils that associate together randomly to form spherical particles at low net charge.

Common motifs in protein self-assembly.

The importance of misfolding proteins forming amyloid fibrils for the aetiology of many diseases, particularly those of old age, is well recognized. This phenomenon is now thought to be a universal property of proteins, as long as appropriate conditions for loosening the native folded structure can be found, which may be outside those of normal physiology. However, the beta-sheet-rich structure of the amyloid fibril does not need to exist in isolation. Recent work has shown that higher order assemblies of the fibrils occur into structures resembling spherulites found in common synthetic semi-crystalline polymers. In these, the fibrils grow outwards from an inner core, thought to be amorphous. Data will be presented on the kinetics of growth of these fibrils for different proteins, so that similarities and differences can be revealed, and related to subtle differences in appearance under the microscope. The in vitro assembly of amyloid fibrils is usually thought to occur well away from the isoelectric point of the protein, and these are the conditions under which they have most been studied. Around the isoelectric point, particulate self-assembly is known to occur for beta-lactoglobulin, and we can now show this is also a generic form of protein self-assembly once the net charge on the protein is close to zero. Nevertheless, the charge is not actually zero, and salt in the solution is found to have a significant effect on the growth of the particles. The use of SAXS, thioflavin T staining and FTIR also shows that within the particles there is also clear evidence for amyloid-like beta-sheet structure, particularly in the case when salt is absent, demonstrating that this particular motif underlies this very different form of protein self-assembly.

Protein particulates: another generic form of protein aggregation?

Protein aggregation is a problem with a multitude of consequences, ranging from affecting protein expression to its implication in many diseases. Of recent interest is the specific form of aggregation leading to the formation of amyloid fibrils, structures associated with diseases such as Alzheimer's disease. The ability to form amyloid fibrils is now regarded as a property generic to all polypeptide chains. Here we show that around the isoelectric point a different generic form of aggregation can also occur by studying seven widely different, nonrelated proteins that are also all known to form amyloid fibrils. Under these conditions gels consisting of relatively monodisperse spherical particulates are formed. Although these gels have been described before for beta-lactoglobulin, our results suggest that the formation of particulates in the regime where charge on the molecules is minimal is a common property of all proteins. Because the proteins used here also form amyloid fibrils, we further propose that protein misfolding into clearly defined aggregates is a generic process whose outcome depends solely on the general properties of the state the protein is in when aggregation occurs, rather than the specific amino acid sequence. Thus under conditions of high net charge, amyloid fibrils form, whereas under conditions of low net charge, particulates form. This observation furthermore suggests that the rules of soft matter physics apply to these systems.

The formation of nematic liquid crystal phases by hen lysozyme amyloid fibrils.

Amyloid fibrils are a polymeric aggregate of protein. The fibrils are typically on the order of micrometers long, with widths of 10-20 nm. They are generally regarded as stiff, and nonbranching. It is well-known that similar synthetic polymers and biopolymers such as DNA and polysaccharides, have a tendency to form liquid crystalline phases when incubated under appropriate conditions. Here we show that amyloid fibrils from the protein hen lysozyme can similarly form liquid crystal phases. The most common phase observed is the nematic. Alignment can persist for several centimeters. When the fibrils are freeze-thawed to shorten them, similar phases form but at higher concentrations, confirming the importance of the aspect ratio of the fibrils. Freeze-thawed fibrils are also seen to form "tactoids", discrete liquid crystalline structures. The addition of NaCl to the solutions appears to only have a minor effect, while the effect of pH appears much more significant. We propose that the consideration of amyloid fibrils as polymer analogues should open new routes to explore in the burgeoning field of biomaterials.

Apomyoglobin reveals a random-nucleation mechanism in amyloid protofibril formation.

Protofibrils (PFs) represent the earliest fibrillar species that occur in the course of amyloid fibril formation. Using apomyoglobin, we report here that PFs arise from a multi-step reaction and that they are preceded by an ensemble of non-fibrillar particles (NFPs). These intermediate aggregates encompass nascent elements of amyloid structure and can act as seeds in PF formation. Taken together with the observation that PFs often protrude from NFPs, our data suggest that PFs form by a random nucleation mechanism in which the polypeptide chains sample many different aggregated conformations. Once the appropriate structural characteristics are acquired, PFs are formed by addition of further polypeptide chains.

Optical microscopy of growing insulin amyloid spherulites on surfaces in vitro.

Amyloid fibrils are often found arranged into large ordered spheroid structures, known as spherulites, occurring in vivo and in vitro. The spherulites are predominantly composed of radially ordered amyloid fibrils, which self-assemble from protein in solution. We have observed and measured amyloid spherulites forming from heat-treated solutions of bovine insulin at low pH. The spherulites form in large numbers as semispherical dome-shaped objects on the cell surfaces, showing that surface defects or impurities, or the substrates themselves, can provide good nucleation sites for their formation. Using optical microscopy, we have measured the growth of individual spherulites as a function of time and in various conditions. There is a lag time before nucleation of the spherulites. Once they have nucleated, they grow, each with a radius increasing linearly, or faster than linearly, with time. Remarkably, this growth period has a sudden end, at which all spherulites in the system suddenly stop growing. A model of spherulite formation based on the polymerization of oriented fibrils around a nucleus, from a precursor in solution, quantitatively accounts for the observed growth kinetics. Seeding of native insulin solutions with preformed spherulites led to the preformed spherulites growing without a lag time. This seeding behavior is evidence that the fibrils in the spherulites assemble from small protein species rather than fibrils. The density of the spherulites was also measured and found to be constant with respect to radius, indicating that the space fills as the spherulite grows.

Aggregation across the length-scales in beta-lactoglobulin.

The protein beta-lactoglobulin (BLG) has been widely studied, in large part because of its importance to the food industry. Following denaturation during heating, under different conditions of pH it has been found to form either particulate (around the isoelectric point at pH 5.1) or fibrillar gels. The nature of the fibrils has recently been suggested to be the same as that identified with amyloid fibrils known for a wide-range of different proteins and implicated in many disease states. We confirm that the BLG fibrils show all the classical signatures of amyloid fibrils. In addition, the fibrils are capable themselves of aggregating further to form large-scale (many microns in size) spherulites. Polarized light microscopy and Environmental scanning electron microscopy (ESEM) have been used to explore the internal structure of these spherulites under conditions in which the solvent has not been dried off. The factors which determine whether or not the spherulites form have also been considered, together with implications for other amyloid-containing systems.

FTIR reveals structural differences between native beta-sheet proteins and amyloid fibrils.

The presence of beta-sheets in the core of amyloid fibrils raised questions as to whether or not beta-sheet-containing proteins, such as transthyretin, are predisposed to form such fibrils. However, we show here that the molecular structure of amyloid fibrils differs more generally from the beta-sheets in native proteins. This difference is evident from the amide I region of the infrared spectrum and relates to the distribution of the phi/psi dihedral angles within the Ramachandran plot, the average number of strands per sheet, and possibly, the beta-sheet twist. These data imply that amyloid fibril formation from native beta-sheet proteins can involve a substantial structural reorganization.

The formation of spherulites by amyloid fibrils of bovine insulin.

Bovine insulin has long been known to self-assemble in vitro into amyloid fibrils. We have observed a further higher-order self-association of the protein into spherical structures, with diameters typically around 50 microm but ranging from 10 to 150 microm. In a polarizing light microscope, these structures exhibit a "Maltese-cross" extinction pattern typical of spherulites. Spherical structures of a similar size distribution can be observed in the environmental scanning electron microscope, which also reveals the presence of significant amounts of water in the structures. The spherulites contain a large quantity of well defined amyloid fibrils, suggesting that they are formed at least in part as a consequence of the self-assembly of preformed fibrils. Similar structures also have been observed in the tissues of patients suffering from amyloid disorders. The ability of amyloid fibrils to form such higher-order assemblies supports the hypothesis that they represent a generic form of polypeptide structure with properties that are analogous to those of classical synthetic polymers.

Observation of sequence specificity in the seeding of protein amyloid fibrils.

It is well established that the rate of formation of fibrils by amyloidogenic proteins is enhanced by the addition of preformed fibrils, a phenomenon known as seeding. We show that the efficiency of seeding fibril formation from solutions of hen lysozyme by a series of other proteins depends strongly on the similarity of their sequences. This observation is consistent with the importance of long-range interactions in stabilizing the core structure of amyloid fibrils and may be associated with the existence of a species barrier observed in the transmissible spongiform encephalopathies. In addition, it is consistent with the observation of a single dominant type of protein in the deposits associated with each form of amyloid disease.